• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Become a Premium Member
  • About

Road Bike Rider Cycling Site

Expert road cycling advice, since 2001

  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • Bikes & Gear
  • Training & Health
  • Reviews
  • Cycling Ebooks
    • Ebooks Training
    • Ebooks Skills
    • E-Articles Training
    • E-Articles Nutrition
  • Member Area
  • Newsletter

Frame and Bikepacking Bag Roundup

By Sheri Rosenbaum

Are you looking for ways to carry more gear on a gravel or overnight ride? Or maybe even on a work commute? Finding the right bag for the adventure can be challenging, but here are a few options depending on your needs.

State Bicycle Co. recently released two types of frame bags and a handlebar bag.

Top Tube Frame Bag

Price: $69.99

Size: 46 W x 12 H x 6 D cm

Capacity: 3 Liters

Material: Waterproof shell

Colors: Black, Olive, Tan

How obtained: Company sample

Availability: Online and retail

RBR advertiser: No

State’s 3-liter capacity Top Tube Frame Bag is well constructed, and the waterproof shell makes it ideal for commuting, gravel, or backpacking adventure. Available in three colors and fits most standard frames (consult the company’s website). Separated pockets and inside zipper pouch help keep items organized; however, the dark fabric makes it hard to find darker items (except for the tan version). One zipper has the easy pull tab making access with gloves no problem.

Wedge Frame Bag

Price: $59.99

Size: 38 cm (top) x 24 cm (sides) x 8 cm (width)

Capacity: 3 Liters

Material: Waterproof shell

Colors: Black, Olive, Tan

If you prefer a wedge-style frame bag, State Bicycle offers a waterproof version in three colors, like the Top Tube bag. However, the capacity is a bit smaller at 2.5 liters. It will hold up to a 2-liter water bladder with an exit sleeve to route a hose. Zipper pockets on both sides of the bag have easy pull zippers allowing you to access items while on the bike or with gloves. Like the Top Tube bag, the inside lining is dark, making it difficult to find dark items.

Handlebar Bag

Price: $39.99

Size: 21 cm L x 9 cm diameter

Capacity: 1.7 liter

Material: Waterproof shell

Colors: Olive

State’s Handlebar bag fits on virtually any flat or drop bar. It has a 1.7-liter capacity, ideal for a phone, tools, and wallet. The waterproof shell keeps items dry no matter the weather. Unfortunately, like the Top Tube bag, the inside lining is black, making it difficult to find dark items inside. There are two zipper pockets, the main compartment and a tiny opening on the endcap. For the life of me, I don’t know what could fit in the endcap except for a few coins, but it’s there if you need it.

Restrap Bar Bags – Large and Small versions

Restrap is a UK family-run company in Yorkshire that prides itself on offering handmade outdoor accessories. I’ll be honest, before receiving the company samples, I had never heard of them, but I’m incredibly impressed with their quality and workmanship. The hangtag even has a QR code to register your product for a lifetime guarantee which shows the company stands behind its products.

Price: $163.99 (small); $194.99(large)

Capacity: 14 liter (small bag); 17 liter total (14L + 3L food pouch large bag)

Weight: 385g (small bag); 550g without food pouch, 656g with pouch (large)

Dry bag: Included

Color: Black w/orange shock cord or all black

How obtained: Company sample

Availability: Online

RBR advertiser: No

Large bar bag with 3L feedbag

Both size bar bags utilize a holster to hold a dry bag that can be filled with whatever you need to carry without needing a rack or mount. The bag attaches to the bars using bar straps with foam spacers and two lower straps that wrap around the fork crown to provide added stability.

The double roll dry bag has taped seams and waterproof coated nylon fabric that lets you store your gear without fear of it getting wet. An elasticized cord on the front of the holster (available in orange or black) provides additional storage for items you might want to access quickly while on the go.

Magnetic system used to attach the pouch to the holster securely

The large bar bag comes with an attachable food pouch so you can grab nutrition on the go. A magnetic system attaches the pouch to the bar bag for added security on rough terrain. The waterproof lining and zipper keep items dry, and quickly find items with a large zipper pull cord and bright orange lining.

Bottom Line

Find the right bag for your next adventure from either State Bicycle Co. or Restrap. Knowing your gear is dry and secure lets you concentrate on other things, like enjoying the ride.


Sheri Rosenbaum regularly contributes articles and reviews products for RBR. She’s an avid recreational roadie who lives in the Chicago area and a major advocate for women’s cycling, serving on the board of directors and volunteering with the Dare2tri Paratriathlon Club. Click to read Sheri’s full bio or visit her web site sunflowersandpedals.com.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Dave Minden says

    September 2, 2022 at 4:39 pm

    Sheri, given the huge range of other bikepacking setups/companies, care to say why you highlighted these companies’ products?

    Reply
    • Sheri Rosenbaum says

      September 25, 2022 at 3:06 pm

      Hi Dave,
      I’ve reviewed several different manufacturers over the years.. These were the bags I received most recently. If you do a site search you’ll find others. If there’s a brand you’d like us to cover please share.
      Sheri

      Reply
  2. Peter Leis says

    September 5, 2022 at 11:21 am

    Hi all,
    I sort of get the Bike Packing thing but have to wonder what is wrong with Racks and Panniers. It seems that most of the “Gravel” bikes have mounts….lots of mounts. My understanding is that Gravel riding is mostly on Gravel roads not single track where you may want the narrower profile. I recently completed the Dempster Highway and the ITH Inuvik Tuktoyuktuk highway to the Arctic ocean 880 K of gravel riding carrying about 65 lbs of gear in Panniers front and rear. Im not sure that frame bags would provide the capacity required.

    Reply
    • Sheri Rosenbaum says

      September 25, 2022 at 3:09 pm

      Peter,
      Frame bags give you options. For instance, many of my bikes do not have a way to attach a rack or paniers, so frame bags are my only option. Also, when doing a one day gravel ride, it’s nice to have additional storage for when you remove clothing layers or nutrition. Some rides you don’t have access to gas stations along the route and need a place for storage. I wouldn’t want the added weight of a rack and paniers.

      It’s all about choices and preference.
      Sheri

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search

Recent Articles

  • Newsletter Issue No. 1053
  • Can you use Shimano rotors with SRAM brakes? (Or vice versa?)
  • 16 Tips for Increasing Your Annual Cycling Mileage
  • Intense Exercisers Have More Plaques but Fewer Heart Attacks

Recent Newsletters

Newsletter Issue No. 1053

Newsletter Issue No. 1052

Newsletter Issue No. 1051

Newsletter Issue No. 1050

Newsletter Issue No. 1049

Footer

Affiliate Disclosure

Our cycling expert editors and writers choose every product we review. We may earn an affiliate commission if you buy from one of our product links, at no extra cost to you. This income supports our site.

Follow Us

  • Pinterest
  • Facebook

Privacy Policy

Still Haven’t Found What You’re Looking For?

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...