HOT!
|
NOT!
|
http://ibikesports.com
Price: $299-$438 MSRP, depending on options Options: ANT+ or ANT+/BLE, PowerStroke, GPS Tracker, Garmin Combo Mount
Product Tested: PowerPod BLE/ANT+ Features: Accurate, affordable, portable ANT+/BLE wireless power meter. Works with free Isaac Power Analysis software.
Requirements: Speed sensor required for PowerPod to work. Cadence gives additional analysis options and slightly faster response to starting/stopping pedaling, but PowerPod will work without cadence.
Source: company website, online How obtained: review sample from Power Meter City RBR sponsor: No Tested: Several months |
What is a PowerPod?
First off, using Google’s search engine, I found hundreds of reviews of the PowerPod. From videos, blogs, websites, periodicals, to you name it, it’s out there. So instead of rehashing the same old “this is what I thought of it after using it for 5 minutes” review, I decided to do more of a complete user experience in setting one of these up, followed by a review after several months of testing.
Everyone remembers the Newton, Velocomp’s first opposing force (i.e., non-direct force) power meter. It was here one day, then gone the next. So, what happened to it? Although they don’t come out and say, my belief is that Garmin happened to it. The Garmin Edge is so popular that my guess is cyclists thought, “I already have a computer or head unit on my bike, why do I need another one? Why would I want yet another thing on my handlebars that duplicates everything that my Garmin or other computer already shows me?”
In a brilliant move, Velocomp took the guts from the Newton, removed the display, added ANT+ and BLE and created a low priced, highly accurate and lightweight power meter that talks to every (GPS) head unit made!
Out of the box, PowerPod is a device that reports power like any other power meter, and can be used simply as that, with no need to ever look further. But for those interested in more data, it can open a whole new world of analysis and awareness of cycling performance and behavior.
How Does it Work?
The old formula Power = Force x Velocity still applies, but how do you get “Force” if there’s nothing hooked to your bicycle that you aren’t pushing on and bending? It’s really very simple. As you ride your bike, opposing forces are working against you. These are wind resistance, gravity (hills), acceleration and friction. When you combine these forces, you get the total opposing force. PowerPod calculates this total opposing force and, knowing how fast you are going and how fast you are spinning your cranks, knows the POWER you need to be outputting to overcome this total opposing force.
But by nature of measuring all these opposed factors, PowerPod doesn’t stop at just being an (affordable) power meter. By measuring a full 11 channels of data, it records and can numerically analyze your power, your efficiency (aero positions, pedaling smoothness, etc.) and even your riding technique (how well do you draft, how much and where do you brake, etc.)
How Easy is it to Set Up?
The PowerPod can, for basic fitness-seeking users, simply be used as a plug-and-play unit. As such, it is significantly more accurate than any activity tracker and allows well-controlled fitness training based on watts.
For advanced cycling users, it is recommended the unit be personally calibrated for the rider. As with most power meters, there are several items that all need to be working together to make for a successful result. In this case, these individual items are:
(a) initially charging the battery on the PowerPod,
(b) downloading and installing the ISAAC (system) software (explained later),
(c) having (or purchasing) a “power-ready” head unit,
(d) purchasing and installing both speed and cadence sensors,
(e) pairing speed and cadence sensors to the head unit,
(f) setting up the PowerPod via ISAAC – set date, time, odometer, sample rates, display units, body weight, etc.,
(g) pairing the PowerPod & sensors first, then
(h) pairing the PowerPod to the head unit (PowerPod won’t connect to a head unit until it has a speed sensor paired to it), and finally
(i) go on a one-time 10-minute out-and-back calibration ride.
These steps are all required, and some in a specific order for this system to work flawlessly. But chin up, it’s not really that bad since this is only a one-time process. So, take your time and do this right, and when it’s done correctly, it’s amazing how easy it is to display and record power when you train, race or even go out on a recovery ride. If in doubt about any of this, Velocomp has a great support/tech person, Tom Gore, as well as a great tech support website.
Moving on, as soon as you open the box, plug your PowerPod into your PC using the supplied USB cable. While the PowerPod is charging, download the free ISAAC Configuration & Analysis software.
ISAAC is just like the PowerPod itself. It can be set up to be extremely simple or very advanced.
Simple ISAAC displays
- Power
- Speed
- Heart rate (optional)
- Elevation
- Map
- Graphic data summary table
- Laps/effort breakdown/map (cloud GPS data can be stitched in from your phone with tracker software upgrade, or your head unit data can be stitched in manually)
By clicking a few option boxes and buying some software upgrades, it can become a very capable and broad-reaching analysis suite. At this detailed end of its scaling up, it allows you to do very in-depth ride analysis to get the most out of your training. ISAAC helps you perform aerodynamic drag (Cda) analysis, rolling resistance, track your distance, energy output, calories burned, power, speed, cadence, wind, elevation totals, energy lost to braking and riding inefficiencies, quality of drafting, and a lot more.
Advanced ISAAC displays
- Power
- Wheel and Wind Speed
- Heart rate (optional ANT+ sensor pairing required)
- Cadence (optional ANT+ sensor pairing required), showing when you draft, too.
- Gear roll-out
- Elevation profile with behavior, displaying where you were pedaling seated, sprinting, freewheeling or braking.
- Incline
- Wasted watts from handling/technique (part of powerstroke upgrade pack)
- The same laps/effort breakdown/map
- Numerical data summary table
I also recommend purchasing the PowerStroke software as it helps you analyze your entire pedal stroke for each leg in detail. Knowing how you are pedaling, you can make changes that will allow you to pedal more efficiently.
This is a very unique analysis, based on accelerations and not the classic pedaling torque metrics many of us have seen or know. This powerstroke analysis tells you how many watts you have wasted from front-to-back surges and side-to-side swaying as you ride. It goes so far as to tell you which % of loss is due to front-to-back or side-to-side individually.
Note: A bike fit by a competent fitter is also highly recommended so that you can be in your most optimal position to take advantage of what ISAAC is helping you with. If you are not fit on the bike correctly, you will not be able to pedal efficiently/effectively. If you aren’t pedaling efficiently/effectively, you can’t apply your potential power – and you also risk injuring yourself. So, get a bike fit as part of your overall training plan!
When installing ISAAC, you will need to sit at your PC for around 10 minutes answering several questions that ISAAC will ask as it installs several drivers. At the same time, I highly recommend that you download the free 80-page ISAAC software instruction manual. Because the PowerPod can be used as far more than just a power meter and ISAAC is a very powerful program that has A LOT of analytical features your average power based software doesn’t need or have. So, it makes sense to read this manual. In the meantime, you can start working on the next task – installing your speed (& optional cadence) sensor(s) onto the bike.
If you have an ANT+ or BLE GPS head unit that displays power, you probably already have a speed sensor installed on your bike. If not, the PowerPod needs a speed sensor to work (a cadence sensor is only a required item if you want to see that data, want faster power response or want to buy the powerstroke upgrade). When installing, follow the supplied directions that came with your PowerPod, making sure to keep magnet-to-sensor clearances to a minimum.
Important note: Contact Velocomp to ask about their current list of approved sensors.
Once the sensors are installed, spin the cranks/wheel a couple of times to wake them up, then pair them to your head unit. At this point, go ahead and attach the supplied mount to the handlebars. Leave it loose, since you will eventually attach the PowerPod, and then you can make the final adjustments. Also, make sure the PowerPod is level and that nothing is blocking its wind port.
While charging, PowerPod’s status light flashes RED. When fully charged, the light turns off. The initial charge takes the longest – a little over an hour. After each ride, I plug my PowerPod into the PC and download the ride data. After about 10 minutes, the PowerPod is back to being fully charged.
Place PowerPod in its new handlebar mount, then tighten the mount so that the PowerPod lettering is parallel to the ground.
Now, let’s pair the PowerPod to the speed & cadence sensors. At this point, it’s best to have the bike in a bike repair stand with the bike being parallel to the ground – how it would sit if it was on the ground – then spin the cranks to wake up the sensors.
Next, PRESS-HOLD PowerPod’s button for 4 seconds to start pairing. Release the button when the status light flashes green. If successfully paired, the status light should be a solid green. Red means unsuccessfully paired. If red, check to see (a) magnets are breaking the sensor fields on their indicated marks and (b) that the distance between the magnets and sensors are a maximum of 2-3mm.
Next, pair your sensors to the head unit. Follow head unit manufacturers’ pairing instructions.
Lastly, we need to pair the PowerPod to your head unit. Follow head unit manufacturers’ pairing instructions here as well.
Pre-Calibration
Reconnect your PowerPod to your PC one last time. Open ISAAC and click DEVICE | CONNECT to test the connection between your new PowerPod and your PC. Once complete, check that you have the latest firmware, then click on DEVICE | SET UP NEWTON to fine-tune your settings. On the final screen, choose BEST ACCURACY, then go out on a one-time 10-minute calibration ride (described below).
Calibration Ride
There are quite a few moving parts that need to come together to make a successful calibration ride. In fact, Velocomp now includes a separate instruction sheet for exactly how to do this with their new PowerPods. Here’s how I did it.
STEP 1 – Plan an out-and-back route prior to doing your calibration ride, preferably with minimal wind, no traffic, no drafting and no stopping. Plan for 5 minutes out and then a return back to your starting point (the outbound leg is defined by 5 minutes’ time, whereas the return leg is defined by distance to return to the starting point). Also, make sure that no cables are blocking the PowerPod’s wind port
STEP 2 – make sure that your head unit is fully charged, that your sensors have fresh batteries and your PowerPod is fully charged. Also, make sure that the sensors and PowerPod have been previously paired to the GPS head unit.
STEP 3 – On your GPS head unit, select a screen that displays POWER. Next, wake up your sensors and make sure your GPS head unit sees them. The best way to do this is to pick the bike off the ground so that the rear wheel can spin freely. Spin the cranks and see if speed and cadence show up on your GPS head unit. The reason for this is that if you perform this test while riding, your head unit will more than likely default to its internal GPS speed and not the speed sensor. Perform this test just prior to your calibration ride.
STEP 4 – Jump right on your bike and turn on your PowerPod by pressing the button. The status light should be SOLID YELLOW = ready to calibrate.
STEP 5 – Ride to your starting point and once at your starting point, come to a COMPLETE STOP. Don’t touch the PowerPod yet. It will do an auto-diagnostic in this period and PowerPod’s light will eventually start flashing RED/GREEN, signaling it is ready.
STEP 6 – Click the PowerPod button. PowerPod should indicate 0 Watts. GREEN/RED flashing light turns to yellow flashing, signaling you can start the out portion of the calibration ride.
STEP 7 –Ride the out portion (about 5 minutes). Your GPS head unit will go from 1W to 50W (indicating 1% to 50% test complete). Once the watts indicate 50, turn around at your convenience then come to a COMPLETE STOP. Just to make sure, unclip both feet. On my calibration run, I ended up riding a little more than 5 minutes out – as long as you don’t ever go below 10mph/16kph during the out portion, the unit will not start the back leg yet.
STEP 8 – Inbound. When you start riding, the watts will indicate 51W to 100W (or 51% to 100% complete).
STEP 9 – When you reach 100W, the flashing yellow light goes out and the PowerPod is now calibrated. Actual watts will now show on the head unit. Now you are good to go!
Remember: This is only a 1-time deal. From here on out, just press the button, a green light should be displayed and the PowerPod will be sending your calculated watts to your head unit.
PowerPod can be used on up to four bikes, and is as easy as a GoPro camera to move from bike to bike on the supplied mounts (additional mounts can be bought from shops or Velocomp’s website). Each bike will need its own unique speed sensor: you will do one of these calibration rides per bike, and the unit will then automatically detect the speed sensor of the bike you have chosen and switch profiles automatically.
Note: At the end of each ride, you will have two ride files. One that will be recorded by your head unit and the other recorded on the PowerPod. You can merge these files using ISAAC. It’s possible to merge these files to gain GPS data or you can buy the “tracker” phone app license to do the same thing automatically through the cloud on every ride. (It is a Strava-like app, just start/end recording as you start and end your ride, the rest is automatic).
The accepted formats are FIT, GPX, TCX, HRM, IBD, as well as some CSV and TXT files. Every so often, ISAAC will ask you whether a ride started where it began, or whether you drafted at all. It does this to dial-in/tweak the PowerPod’s settings for an even more accurate calibration. What this also is good for is to check that your settings are correct – rider weight, bike weight, tire size, etc. The more accurate the data in, the more accurate the data out.
As a bonus feature, the PowerPod can also be used with your rollers or trainer. (But I’ll let you walk through the setup for that feature on your own, if you so choose.)
How Accurate is PowerPod?
On Velocomp’s website, there are several long-term comparison studies that show only a 2.5% difference between the PowerPod (and/or Newton) and another direct-force power meters (DFPM). Where the single-leg DFPM’s let us down is for those cyclists who favor one leg over the other – which, as it turns out, applies to most of us.
Let me give you an example. Most single-leg power meters are set up to measure your left-leg power only. They take your left-leg’s number, multiply it by 2.0 and shoot this up to your head unit for you to view as total power. Many claim a +/- 2% accuracy (left leg only), but, the BIG assumption here is that both legs need to output the same power for this data to be useable.
As a bike fitter and USAC coach, I put clients on my Computrainer, which measures their left and right power. 99% of cyclists I have measured have a large power discrepancy between their left leg and right leg. Most cyclists I have measured on the Computrainer are initially 60%/40%. About half favor the right leg, half favor the left leg. Right leg dominant vs. left leg dominant does not seem to apply here. Me included. I am right hand and right leg dominant and when I first tested myself, I was 60% left leg and 40% right leg. Knowing this, I have been able to work on balancing out my power to 50%/50% over a 3-month period. Although PowerPod does not measure right and left legs separately, PowerStroke (software analysis) isavailable that can help you analyze this.
Unless your left/right legs are pretty equal (which, in my experience and observations that is NOT the case with most of us), a single-leg DFPM can be way off from actual total power. The way PowerPod’s algorithms work make it much closer to what a dual-leg power meter would indicate. Even though PowerPod does not actually measure nor report left/right power, it is still more accurate than a single-sided DFPM in most cases.
PowerPod actually measures your total power needed to maintain a given speed. So, as a side-effect of their algorithm, PowerPod does combine your left leg power + right leg power to get total power.
What about compared to a true dual-leg/dual-sided power meter? This solution can be the most accurate and can definitely help in training to use both legs equally – but at what cost? At the time of publication, a basic ANT+ PowerPod is $299. To compare, a true dual-sided power meter like Pioneer with head unit (to display leg vector analysis) is $1,100-$2,000 (depending on Ultegra/Dura-Ace and if you supply crankset or use theirs), Rotor is $1,200-$1,500, 4iiii is $750 your crankset or $1,500 their crankset. These are the ultimate power meters since they measure each leg independently. The only drawback is their high cost. At $299, the PowerPod is still the power meter of choice for most of us.
How Did it Work?
When all is said, and done, it comes down to (a) how easy is it to operate and (b) how easy is it to get the data from.
Again, if you take your time prepping, setting up, installing, etc., you can now enjoy its ease of use. When I take my bike out of the car, the first thing I do is turn on the head unit. While I’m getting dressed, the head unit is initializing and finding its required number of GPS satellites to operate. After I clip in, I hit the PowerPod’s power button and after 1-2 pedal strokes I am shown power, cadence, heart rate, etc. – whatever I have selected on my Bryton 530 head unit.
Post-ride, I plug the PowerPod into the PC and open ISAAC, which I have set to automatically download the PowerPod data file. From here, I can analyze the ride within ISAAC or with one click of the mouse, upload the data to Training Peaks or even export the data to CSV, GPX, TCX, PWX or KML to analyze in WKO4.
Truly powerful!
The Last Word
Lately, power meters have dropped quite a bit in price. But, with the PowerPod priced at $299, the others must reduce their prices by at least another 50% more to even get close. Only PowerPod works with any pedals, cranks, and wheels, provides both-leg power measurement, and is as easy to move from bike to bike.
With its optional upgrades, it also becomes more than just a power meter, allowing you to analyze and improve technique, like how well you draft, how much and where you brake, how many watts you lose through pedaling and bike-handling inefficiencies, and even a basic wind tunnel function is in development for people with approved classic power meters.
March 2017
Coach Rick Schultz is an avid cyclist who trains, races and coaches in Southern California. Rick is an engineer by trade, and in addition to being a coach, he’s a bike fitter and prolific product reviewer. He’s the author of Stretching & Core Strengthening for the Cyclist and Bike Fit 101: Your Toolset for a Great Bike Fit in the RBR eBookstore. Check his product reviews website, www.biketestreviews.com, and his coaching site, www.bikefitnesscoaching.com. Click to read Rick’s full bio.
do you have to plug it in to send data to the PC?
what can you actually see when riding, and what do you have to add, to see it?
(it sounds like you have to have a gps with ANT, and you can only see “power”..)
Do you have to have GPS for it to work? Touring can get me to places without GPS. Previously I owned a Garmin Dakota 20 but ditched it and went back to a bike computer without GPS as I need to count on distance/time/etc. and GPS wasnt’ reliable out in the distant countryside.
No GPS needed. Assuming you have a GPS enabled head unit, through Isaac, you can combine both files so the resulting file will have a route map. Remember, both units (powerpod + head unit) are recording the ride. The Powerpod needs a speed sensor to work, but, since most speed sensors also come with a cadence sensor, this combination actually makes the data more accurate.
HI, this works like any ‘other power meter’, stages, pioneer, rotor in the sense that these are only power meters and report only power. It is up to the head unit to calculate and display all other data like cadence, speed, %grade, power, avg this, max that, except the PP also captures spin and cadence (with both sensors) and Isaac processes post ride for you to analyze the ride. Remember, most processing other than power, cadence is calculated by the GPS head unit. The more $$ the head unit, the more data it can calculate and display and the more color screens you get.
“GPS wasn’t reliable out in the distant countryside”
This statement boggles my mind, as GPS should work better in wide open spaces, not worse… unless you were in some steep-sided canyons or something where you had no satellite visibility. Care to elaborate?
Added on behalf of Coach Rick Schultz (Bike Fitness Coaching):
Yes. It has enough memory and battery life for half a dozen or so rides. But, if you are into analytics, its best to plug it into the PC after the ride and tell ISAAC to download the ride file. After downloaded, the PP will be in charge the battery mode.
Bottom line, its actually a very high quality power meter at a really affordable price.
Yes, with a usb connection. The unit is removable, but you can connect it when the unit is on the bike. I store my bike in my office and I havea hub and cables long enough to reach and just have it connected on the bike.
One thing to note: the unit can pivot on the mount. At first I was getting some inconsistent numbers, but then I re-read the instructions and saw the step that said to make sure the unit is always pushed back all the way. I check this before every ride now (because like I said the unit pivots and can get inadvertently pushed forward a little in transit), and now my numbers are very consistent and I love the product. Also, I had a problem with the first unit I got and the replaced it no questions asked!
This is really interesting. Any feedback on the software interfacing with a MAC to download and analyze data?
http://www.ibikesports.com/support/isaac-software-downloads/ scroll down to “Mac Users” or, just type this into your browser – http://www.ibikesports.com/iBike_update/Isaac_for_Mac.zip
Good point! Thanks
I do most of my training indoors. Can it measure power whilst static
The PowerPod can be used on indoor trainers by turning on the trainer mode found on the Isaac download. Click device and turn on indoor trainer mode. Using the known power curve for almost any trainer on the market allows the PowerPod to calculate power. My understanding is this function can also be used for online training such as Zwift, making a standard trainer a “smart” trainer. One note I recently learned, orginally the indoor trainer mode automatically tuned itself off when you rode outside as the PowerPod picks up wind speed. Since some of us use fans while training indoors, it was reading wind and automatically changing over to outside mode. Now you are required to turn the indoor mode off and on for your type of workout.
Another major advantage of the PowerPod is that it is not susceptible to temperature drift like every other DFPM out there. Since it does no rely on “bending” metal, which changes stiffness with temperature, the power calculation is not affected when you start out on a chilly morning ride and the temperature heats up several degrees during the next several hours. DFPM’s must be recalculated to provide accurate power data with temperature changes. Try doing that recalibration on a long change, where temperatures can drastically drop as your altitude increase.
Lastly, I don’t believe a head unit is necessary for using the PowerPod since it is self contained. If you wish to see the numbers during your ride, you’ll need a ANT+ or BLE head unit. You can also upgrade to the PowerHouse ap and use your smartphone. With the optional Tracker GPS upgrade will get you the GPS tracking info if you don’t have a GPS unit such as a Bryton Computer (lover my 530!).
I have a new Giant Defy with Ride sense which I have synced with my Garmin 530. Do you think that it is possible to install a Garmin rotary speed sensor , sync the power pod to the garmin speed sensor , but do not sync the speed sensor to the 530.- then sync the power pod to the 530. I do not want to remove the ride sense. and I have a garmin speed sensor that I am not using. I am going to give this a try as I understand that the power pod does not work with Giant Ride sense.
FYI it worked. Only the ride sense speed and cadence sensor is synced to the Edge 530. I put the Garmin rotary speed sensor on the front wheel of the bike and synced it with the power pod without activating the ride sense.
I synced the power pod with the 530 which produced a yellow light. I went for the calibration ride and now the power pod is transmitting accurate power readings to the 530. It might be a little bit late to react to abrupt power output changes but I use this bike only for long consistent speed rides and I am primarily interested in average power readings.
Despite downloading the silicone labs drivers, my PowerPod v3 will not connect to Isaac.
IN A NUTSHELL: RETARDED SETUP PROCESS. TOO CONVOLUTED. BUTTON FLASHING COLORS AND STEADY COLORS AND DIFFERENT LIGHT COMBO INTERPRETATIONS ARE FREAKIN TOO COMPLICATED…
When I try to pair the yellow light only stays on for a few seconds and I am unable to complete the pairing.