• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Become a Premium Member
  • About

Road Bike Rider Cycling Site

Expert road cycling advice, since 2001

  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • Bikes & Gear
  • Training & Health
  • Reviews
  • Cycling Ebooks
    • Ebooks Training
    • Ebooks Skills
    • E-Articles Training
    • E-Articles Nutrition
  • Member Area
  • Newsletter

Why is my heart rate on the trainer different than in an outdoor race?

QUESTION: Hello: I am trying to reconcile my power and heart rate data. During a 2022 New England hillclimb, my normalized power for about 90 minutes was 193 watts, and my average heart rate was 168 bpm. During a one hour indoor training ride this weekend, my normalized power was about the same at 196 watts, but my average heart rate was only 139 bpm. Why would it be so much lower for about the same power? – Mark G

RBR REPLIES: This is an intriguing question, because usually you hear cyclists report that they can achieve higher power numbers riding outdoors compared to indoor training.

There could be a few reasons why your heart rate was lower during your indoor training ride despite having a similar normalized power compared to your New England hill climb.

Environmental factors such as temperature and humidity can affect your heart rate. For example, if your indoor training setup was cooler and less humid compared to the New England hill climb because you have good AC and fans at home, your heart rate may have been lower because of that.

What was the race itself like? It is possible that you blew up early in the hill climb and were pushing much higher watts in the beginning and then dropped down to a much lower wattage on later parts of the climb after you blew up? This could give you a lower normalized power for the overall hill climb even with a really hard start.

Are you using the same bike and power meter on the trainer that you used in the race? It it possible that the power meter on the trainer had not been calibrated with a zero offset? Is it possible that the bike on the trainer was using estimated power and not measuring your actual power? I’ve seen stories of riders winning Zwift races riding a trainer with no power meter because it was exaggerating the estimated wattage.

Instead of just looking at your raw normalized power number, have you looked at your watts per kilogram? If you check your watts per kilogram, you can compare that to the wattage for a typical Zwift A, B or C racer, and then also check it against a typical USAC racer in your category for a reality check for both rides. Which ride seems more reasonable as far as w/kg?

Is your fitness different now than it was then? It is possible that you’ve been training a lot since that race and are just fitter? It’s possible to get quite a bit fitter in a matter of months — and also to lose fitness pretty quickly if you stop training.

Readers, did I leave any ideas out?

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Gen says

    March 30, 2023 at 5:28 am

    overtraining can impact heart rate too.

    Reply
  2. Bike Fitness Coach says

    March 30, 2023 at 7:14 am

    There is more resistance on a trainer than on the road. Basically, out on the road, you are pedaling directly via chain onto the rear wheel. On a trainer, there is a transmission and other mechanicals that take away power “to the rear wheel” therefore it takes more power to pedal through these added inherent resistances on the trainer

    Reply
  3. Mark Greenleaf says

    March 30, 2023 at 7:40 pm

    Hi RBR: This is Mark G with replies to your questions: My indoor setup is roughly 65 degF with fans, and the race (MWARBH) was about 71degF to start, and decreasing over the course of the climb to the 50’s. My wattage was pretty consistent, from 240 normalized power at the start to 193 after 90 minutes, with a nearly straight-line decline over the 90 minutes (i.e., no blow-up). I use the same bike and crank-arm power meter both outside and on rollers inside. Both outside and inside are measured with a Sigma bike computer, and I also use Rouvy inside. My watts/kg is similar both inside and outside. I was actually fitter for the race, as I’m just starting to resume my training as of January. In response to Gen, I suppose I could have overtrained. In response to bike Fitness Coach, I use my road bike both inside and outside. Any additional thoughts? Thank you.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search

Recent Articles

  • Should I ride narrower tires on my road bike?
  • Smith Optics Shift Split MAG Sunglasses Review
  • Installing a Turbo Road Remote on a Specialized Turbo Creo SL Comp E5 Road Ebike
  • Does Direction Matter on Directional Road Bike Tires?

Recent Newsletters

Newsletter Issue No. 1071

Newsletter Issue No. 1070

Newsletter Issue No. 1069

Newsletter Issue No. 1068

Newsletter Issue No. 1067

Footer

Affiliate Disclosure

Our cycling expert editors and writers choose every product we review. We may earn an affiliate commission if you buy from one of our product links, at no extra cost to you. This income supports our site.

Follow Us

  • Pinterest
  • Facebook

Privacy Policy

Still Haven’t Found What You’re Looking For?

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...