|

Indoors or Outside: Which Is Better for Winter Training?

By Ric Stern

I don’t know about you, but here the weather is a bit rubbishy. It varies between miserable, damp rain and cold, or super sunny bright sunlight and a very low sun. I don’t really like riding in either.

The poor weather affects my Still’s disease, and cycling in such cold, damp conditions feels like my joints are moving through molasses. I get Raynaud’s in my fingers, my power drops, and it’s all very unenjoyable. Then we get bright sunny days — so long as it doesn’t get much below 46°F (8°C) my joints are OK, but hey ho, I spend the entire ride panicking badly that some idiot in a car is about to run me over. They can barely avoid me in decent weather, add in a low glare sun and it feels like I’m trying to dodge a bullet.

So, a lot of the time I ride indoors. Do you, or do you stop riding in the winter?

Evidence from many research papers shows that detraining occurs faster than the Bullet Train and that you lose your fitness super quickly. One year I just rode once a week in the winter. April turned up and come the races I found myself waving goodbye to everyone. It took until September to get race fit, just as the race season was finishing. I wasn’t a happy chappy!

I’m frequently asked, which is better, training indoors or outside? Which produces the best results? I think the question isn’t as easy to answer as people think.

Firstly, with the advent of indoor virtual riding like Rouvy and Zwift etc., this has dramatically improved riding indoors. I recall having a turbo trainer (what we call an indoor trainer in the UK) and staring at a blank wall while I rode. Even with music on, or watching a film or a bike race, I found it soul-destroyingly boring. A bit like watching paint dry. I still did it, but session duration was limited to about 60 minutes and even then it felt like my brain would explode!

That said, I still find riding indoors terminally boring. Without doubt though, virtual riding (so long as you train properly) is an ideal way to maintain or improve your fitness in the more inclement months.

There’s a variety of things I do to try and make the experience better.

Find the virtual system you like. Some people prefer Zwift, others Rouvy, but there’s others as well such as MyWhoosh. Personally, I prefer Rouvy — I quite like the video and routes that are available. Try them all out and see which you prefer.

Music. I like my classic rock, blues, and rock ’n’ roll pumping out while I smash my way up the various climbs on Rouvy (usually Alpe d’Huez). I’m not sure what my neighbors think, but no one has ever complained.

Routes. On Rouvy there’s an absolute ton of routes, but some of them, while I like looking at the scenery, don’t inspire me to ride correctly. I’ll just dawdle along really slowly and then start checking my phone. I haven’t discovered why this happens with some routes, but it’s a definite issue for me.

Plan. Have a training plan. Whether that’s from me, another coach, or one you’ve made yourself. Don’t get on the trainer without one — unlike being stuck 50 miles from home (you’re sorta forced to ride home!) you can get off the turbo without a second thought. Ours is set up in the dining room, so if it goes pear-shaped I can be off the bike and on the couch in seconds. Having a plan helps us to stick with it. This does not mean you should be doing intervals every day. Your plan can include endurance work. Today’s ride I’d wanted to ride for 90 minutes at endurance pace but didn’t feel I had the mental capacity to keep going, so I did 10 minutes on, 5 minutes dawdling until I got to 90 minutes. Not bad, it’s a start and I’ll push it up as I get more accustomed to indoor riding.

Indoor trainer. What can I say — they’ve changed dramatically over the last decade or so. Mine is quiet and responsive. And can take a beating when doing sprints on it.

A fan. Yes, you need to turn it off if you’re going to do heat training, but by and large you’ll probably want a big fan with decent airflow.

Nutrition. I’m not sure why, and riders I coach have said the same thing, but for some reason it felt odd eating when riding indoors, like it was something we shouldn’t do. And take a gel? Not a chance. I’ve changed my thinking on that and gel up on my rides indoors now. But, I’ll also take a quick break on longer rides (more than 2 hours) and maybe make myself a Marmite sandwich (if you have no idea what Marmite is, and it generally isn’t available Stateside, it’s my favorite thing after butter to put on bread, and well worth trying if you’re ever in the UK). And, don’t forget to drink indoors, you’ll likely sweat at a higher rate than outdoors.

Riding outdoors on the other hand is generally nicer, and maybe where you are doesn’t have awful weather and a low sun (yup, the US is massive and the weather is hugely varied from one coast to the other). It’s also most likely how we got into cycling.

Does it matter if you stop riding over the winter? Well yes and no, it depends what you’re looking for. With time off your fitness drops which can have negative implications as we age, plus it may lead to weight gain. We could replace cycling with another exercise that is “easier” to do in the winter — there’s virtually no skiing here, but that’s a possibility for some of the US, there’s running, hiking, and the gym. It’ll also depend on what your goals are for next year.

But the main question, which is better (and I obviously think that cycling year-round is the correct answer — at least for me) indoors or out? Honestly, I think we should try and do both. I know my endurance drops a little with indoor riding — outside I can regularly clock up 4+ hour rides, but indoors that’s some epic mental strain (5 hours is my indoor PR and that was no fun at all!).

If you’d like a coach-built plan for the winter, MAP: The Build gives you a training program built around your fitness, goals, and available time, updated every four weeks, for £25 (about $34) per block.

Find out more about MAP: The Build here.

Have a training question for Ric?

Ric Stern has spent decades answering riders’ training questions and has coached cyclists since 1997, from club racers to Paralympic medallists and Tour de France professionals. Cardiovascular fitness, strength training, VO2 max, race tactics, nutrition, or whatever is keeping you from a stronger season: ask away. We publish questions using your first name and last initial only.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨


Coach Ric Stern is the founder of CycleCoach. He holds a first-class degree in Sport Science, has published peer-reviewed research in exercise physiology, and has coached riders from track sprint through to ultra-endurance and the Tour de France.

At 57, he’s still racing himself and is fitter now than he was in his 20s.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *