Comment on Newsletter

Comment here on the current newsletter issue, or about anything you see on the site. All we ask is that you maintain civility and respect for your fellow cyclists. Thanks.

(Note: If you are already logged into the site, please scroll to the bottom of the page to add a new comment.)

Maximum Heart Rate

Please clarify for me the definition of the maximum heart rate formula. Does the 220 minus age = maximum heart rate.... or 90% of maximum heart rate?Thanks, Bill Slavin, aging newbie

Crank Length

Jim, I appreciated your two-part article on reducing crank length. I switched to 180mm last year from 175, but I am 6'-2" with a 34.5" inseam. The length helps me feel like I am using more of my muscle groups, but that is subjective. Based on your results, I might put the 175's back on to see how they feel.

You mentioned saddle height adjustment with changing crank lengths, but did you mention saddle fore/aft position? With a shorter crank, to maintain knee over pedal, you need to slide the saddle aft about 1/3 the difference. For 5 mm shorter crank, moving the saddle rearward 2 mm would maintain KOP. This assumes a good position was attained prior.

Contador

My big questions are, who was the "AC" that the Spanish Federation catagorically stated was NOT Contador in the Fuentes files, and why did they clear him so quickly in the clenbuteral case ?

Crank Arm Length Rebuttal

http://cervelo.com/en_us/news-blog/article/crank-length/2954/--Whole article above, summary below."What does the Race Engineer say? As Team Garmin-Cervélo’s Race Engineer, I advise athletes to choose whatever crank length they like. Those who are interested may try shorter cranks on the TT bike; in that case I usually recommend a 5mm difference: longer on the road bike than the TT bike. In all cases, regular training on the TT bike is important to promote adaptation to all aspects of the aero position. The main thing is to realize that the choice of crank length doesn’t significantly affect power, so any length is now free to choose for any other reason. This lets the athletes relax about crank length, knowing it’s not as critical as we used to think. Dr. Martin’s results are not widely understood yet, so crank length is still controversial, and many athletes have strong preferences on crank length."Note: I (rick) am not the Race Engineer, I am only forwarding on this information to the readers.....

Crank Length??

Hi, Interesting subject  this, Back in 1969  I was hit from behind while riding home from a Part timeDrinkwaiters job in Richmond . Melbourne, Aust.the Bar.....  did not stop.After 4 mths in hospital fixing breaks to my right femur and my right ancle  I finished uplearning to walk and Ride again, but my Right leg is1inch and 1/4 shorter than my Left legI did not limp as my Hips Dropped to make up the difference, but my cycling was all wrong,after much messing around by shortening Cranks I came up with the Solution I fitted a new Modified Right Hand Pedal on top of the existing one with Plates and Bolts and without the central fixing spindle.Result is I now enjoy perfect Pedal action and Leg rotations.I hope that this will help others in a similar situation.

Clentador

The system stinks. The national federations should not have jurisdiction on doping cases, they have too much potential for conflict of interest. The UCI is also corrupt and incompetent.  Cobo wins the Vuelta and Jeannie Longo is winning races in her 50's and her husband gets busted for epo purchases. What hapenned to the "biological passport"?

Contador & racing

As stated, you get one chance to stand on the podium and smile and  here the cheers and feel like a winner. The rider should be given a choice. Take the 2 year ban now and not race or race or if found guily, race and take the chance of being stripped, and have the ban doubled, in this case to 4 years. This would have prevented Contador from racing for two years, or any other guilty party. Contador should have been stripped as he was, and then the ban should move forward another 2 years.

Pinched Nerve

An update. I've had the workup/x-rays. I have bone spurs at  C5-7 which, undoubtedly have inflamed the nerve(s). We have started physical therapy in hopes of avoiding surgery. First are exercises to strengthen the muscles in that area which may (that's MAY) move the nerves away from the spurs and lessen the inflamation, and traction. The latter has helped! As I understand it this too may result in lessening the inflamation by increasing the distance where the nerves exit the spine. However, obviously traction is not a cure since I'll eventually shrink again. Hopefully the two combined will eliminate the surgery option. Time will tell. Randy D.

Pinched nerve

Also try softening your elbows and relaxing your shoulders so they don't hunch up toward your ears.  Good Luck!

nerve pain

I believe you are suffering from a condition called brachial plesus nueritis, its caused by an infalmation of the muscle that runs down the side of  your back and under your shoulder.  This muscle becomes inflamed and pinches on the brachial plexus which is the main junction box for nerves that run down your arm and also into your back and neck.. I have had this condition and it is the most painful thing I've ever had, and I have been through the ringer. the cure is to reduce the the inflamaton with muscle relaxers and a heating pad place under the arm pit  around toward the back where the muscle resides. You should be able to actually feel the muscle being much larger then the one on the other side.  Hope this helps

Pinched nerve in neck

In my experience as a Licensed Massage Therapist, I've come across this type of neck pain often. In many cases, if levator scapula is in spasm it can mimic a pinched nerve, partially because it may be compressing the nerve. Find a good massage therapist, one with experience in orthopedic and/or sports massage, to help you. They should not only address the muscle in question, but all muscles acting on the scapula, specifically the lateral scapula. Also, until a more serious condition is ruled out, traction of the neck (by a massage therapist) should be avoided. I've had a lot of success treating this condition.Please note this is not meant as medical advice or a diagnosis/assessment; just an alternative suggestion.

Crank length

John, you left out one obvious choice:  "No, but I've considered longer cranks"  As a long-legged rider, I'm more likely to experiment with longer cranks than shorter ones.

Contador: Did the Punishment Fit the Crime

My congratulations, John - you just lost your chance to have me as a premium member- I was going to subscribe for Premium Mebership today, but your article brought me to a full stop. Never (or at least for a long time) have not read something so biased.Let go into details:Firstly, banning Contrador for 2 years from now does NOT go well  along with the stripping him of results acquired after his acquital by the national federation - it would essentially mean 3-years ban, somewhat too steep for a unintentional offence (and the CAS desicion is based on the "tainted supplement" hypothesis which assume no intent to dope).Secondly, it again demonstrated that a concept of "ultimate responsibility" is just ridiculous - wit an increased sensitivity of the tests we may easily reach the level when some banned substance may be found in the blood or urine of every person in the world. Moreover, when so low levels are detectable by some (a few or even one) laboratory it very well may mean that even a level in the source (would it be tainted meat, tainted supplement or whatever) may be  low enough tobe undetectable in an average laboratory. Then how rider could be hold responsible for it?Thirdly, it showed (again and again) that a doping justice process is terriibly unbalanced (and not in the favor of rider).Forthly, it does not look fair when a rider is stripped from titles that he acquired when he rided legally after acquital and not as direct result of the doping offence that was incriminated to him. Let us consider an example - some one commited the crime but was first acquited, then sentenced to jail, would it be proper and fair to strip him from his salary for the period between acquital and sentancing on the reason that he shall be in the jail all this time and so shall be unabe attend his job? From my point of view this amounts to a pure nonsense (save probably the case this person acquired his job as a direct result of the crime).Regards,Aleksander 

I Value Your Right to Express Your Opinion

Aleksander,I value your right to express your opinion. I'm sorry you don't seem to value my right to do the same. It is just an opinion, after all. I sure don't expect everyone to agree with everything I say. I know my wife, for one, doesn't!--John

Flying Coach

OJ Simpson used to fly through airports and he never got clots.  Was he a coach?Just askin'.Ted.

Cramps

I finally solved my leg muscle cramping problem by:  drinking a lot more sports drinks with the highest sodium content I can find (such as EFS by First Endurance), taking Hammer Endurolite capsules and Saltstick capsules.  I'm a huge fan of drinking pickle juice and/or adding some soy sauce to my water bottles when it's especially hot/humid weather.  

Niterider MiNewt 600

I rec'd one of these amazing lights for Christmas.  After using it for about 6 weeks, I would give it a 5 star rating.

Pedaling style and calf cramps

Your recommendation to move cleats back to reduce the risk of cramping is confusing to me. Presumably cramps occur because of persistent contraction of the calf muscle. Rear ward cleats would likely increase calf muscle contraction because of the resulting tendency of the toes to point down during the pedal stroke. Moving the cleats forward would be more likely to reduce stress on the calf muscle due to the tendency for the heel to drop. Am I confused?

Yes, you are confused

Yes, Dick, you are confused - but it's easy to get confused with cleat adjustments. In any case, when you move the cleats back on the shoes, you put more of your foot on the pedal which means you are less likely to pedal with your toes. Moving the cleat forward does the opposite so that's what you want to avoid. Most riders can feel this right away. If the cleat is too far forward you feel like you're pedaling with too little of your foot. Moving the cleats back feels more secure, stable and for many riders more comfortable. The trick is figuring out how far back and that depends on how you ride. A good starting position is having the ball of the feet over the pedal axle. That works for a lot of people. If you're into long rides like double centuries or even longer, moving the cleats further back can be more comfortable and prevent long-distance issues like hot foot and numbness.Hope this helps,Jim Langley

bike fit best thing for cyclists

I had a bike fit by Andy Pruit and it was the best thing that I have ever done for myself in bicycle terms. Before the fit I was having so much lower back pain and knee pain that I thought that I was going to have to quit cycling. Now I still have pain for time to time, but I feel like I've stepped back in time concerning my pain issues.  I would recommend a good fit for every bicyclist.

bike fit

Glad to hear that your bike fit by Andy Pruitt worked well for you. I an a big fan of Andy's and am still using the orthotics he fitted me for in 1993. And Andy and his orthopedist partner Jim Holmes saved my knee when I hurt it downhill skiing some years ago. It's amazing how a good bike fit can improve your power and cycling enjoyment.Fred Matheny

bikefit

Where can I get one of these great bike fits in Texas?  I have tried local bike shops but they know less than me.

Bike fit

I have had a bike fit done by Kevin Livingston @ MEllow Johhny's in Austin.  He does the fit using the RETUL system, and did a great job for both myself and my wife.  Another option is contact Knobbies and Slicks in Colleyville (near Ft Worth) - They did a RETUL fit for me prepatory to buying a new bike.  If you are near San Antonio, then go to Bike World in Alamo Heights - Again they did a great job for me before I bought a Ritchey Breakaway (for sale by the way). 

Richardson Bike Mart in the

Richardson Bike Mart in the Dallas TX area has RETUL fittings.  Worth it - easily.  'nuff said.  

Pedaling style and calf cramps

Coach Fred, I wish I had seen your comments years ago, because it would have saved me from a lot of calf cramping.  I have experienced cramps due to all the things you mentioned.The closest thing to a magic bullet for me was cleat placement--and I only found this 1 year ago.  I moved the cleat as far back as possible, and the improvement in my duration before cramping was immediate.  If I could move them further back without needing custom shoes, I would do it.  I have even seen the effects on the size of my calves, after a thousand miles or so--they used to be out of proportion with my thighs. My calves will always remain as the first to fail, and are my first indicators that hydration, electrolytes, or general fitness are out of balance.  But, it's good to keep them at bay for a lot longer now.

cramps

It's good to hear that you have calf cramps under control. I agree that moving cleats rearward helps and according to at least some studies, improves power too. I have been most successful in avoiding cramps on long, hot rides by adding a pinch of salt to each bottle of sports drink. In fact I carry a fast food restaurant packet of salt in a plastic bag in my jersey pocket when I expect to encounter cramp-producing situations.Fred Matheny

Crankarm Length

Along with those seeking improved pedal stroke smoothness by having invested money and training time in Computrainer/SpinScan and/or PowerCranks I'd like to find out how their efforts fit with the downstroke emphasis. 

Niacin

One thing I failed to mention was the Niaspan "flushing".  I'm on a very heavy dose of Niaspan (Niacin) @ 2500 mg per day.  I take these at night before going to bed.  The reason is that if I 'flush', it is while I'm sleeping and I'm less aware of this, and also I won't be cherry red while out in public.WHEN I get flushing from Niaspan....it happens when I get over-heated, nervous, excited, stressed-out....the ITCH is so intensive that no matter how hard you scratch or where you scratch...there is more deep ITCHING farther down beyond reach, or in so many spots you don't know where to try to scratch first.My skin will splotch all over...but mostly face, arms, and chest areas.  This will last for about 1-2 hours and go away as fast as it comes on.  It doesn't happen often, but when it does, it certainly gets my attention from the hot flashes and that ITCHING.Just so you all know about this reaction, should you start a Niacin regimen. I've been at this dosage for 12 years now...and my cholesterol, LDL/HDL, and all that are really on the near perfect side...and LOW.  Take me off those meds, however, and I'm a BAD cholesterol manufacturing machine...I'd be up over 300 within weeks!  You don't beat this out of your DNA with out help, haha T3flats

Cholesterol and riding

I'm on a pretty heavy dosage of cholesterol medications:10/40 Vitorin 2x per day2500 mg Niaspan 1x per day50 mg Metropolol 1x per day250 mg Aspirin 1x per dayNitro pills...when/if needed (rarely).This is also coupled with triple by-pass surgery in the year 2000.I have a cholesterol check every 6 months, and the good news is that my TOTAL cholesterol hovers around 123-126 consistently.My Triglycerides are around 46HDL around 44LDL around 68  with the ratio hovering around 1.4That is the good news!  Now for the bad news!IF I 'over-do' it on a ride, especially on warmer days, I am asking for some extreme adductor muscle cramps sometime after these longer and intense rides.  We are talking EXTREME pain from these cramps.  They can occur right away after a ride, even in spite of stretching out and making sure I'm hydrated, to 12 hours after the ride.  I'll be sitting or lying down and all of a sudden the adductors will seize up, sometimes BOTH legs at the same time, rendering me totally helpless and in agony.Strange thing is I rarely get calf cramps and only suffer minor discomfort/fatigue in the quads.  When I cramp it is almost always the adductors.I, too, have taken CoQ10, and it seems to help; or does it?  Something else I've become religious about taking are Hammer Nutrition's ENDUROLYTE Tablets.  THOSE, along with staying hydrated do indeed HELP with this cramping.  I take 3 tablets about an hour before the ride, and depending upon temperature and how hard I'm riding, I will take 2 or 3 tablets per hour during the ride.  I make sure I'm well hydrated, and, after the ride, I will get some protein into me and hydrate some more.  In addition, of course is a pretty extensive (but NOT intensive) series of cool down exercises to try to 're-stretch' those adductors back into submission.  I don't force these, but found that if I don't do this, I'm going to cramp.The combination of the CoQ10 and Endurolytes do seem to HELP...Most times I will "feel" the potential to cramp, but the cramps won't seize up.  If I've done the Endurolyte routine, the cramps, if I get them, are also less severe; that is, instead of the 4-5 waves of them hitting me over and over, I'll get only 2 or 3.It seems that I only ever get one series of these cramps...but they strike without warning; I'll be fine one second and the next, I'm completely at their mercy and debilitated.My riding group get on me about not pressing it too hard and "you won't get stronger if you don't push it to the brink."  I tell them that "I don't want the "elephant back" and also, that they've seen me cramp up...do YOU want either of those things?"I average between 6500-7500 miles per year on my road bikes, play racquetball 3 times a week, and other than the debilitating horrible excruciating adductor cramps, road biking is the most enjoyable activity I can think of.  I have no intentions of quitting, and of course, my cardiologist is luvin' the activity level....Now, how to get rid of the pot belly....the cardiologist isn't at all concerned about it...but I certainly care, haha.T3flats

Compression?

You didn't mention it, but I'm wondering if you wear any sort of compression socks or leg sleeves after riding? For the past several months, after my post-ride shower (especially after hard rides) I will slip on my to-the-knee compression socks and wear them the rest of the day. Sometimes, I even sleep in them! I have one knee in which the patella often slips out of the groove and used to cause a lot of post-ride pain. And both knees have always felt very tired after rides. Now, with the compression, I can feel an almost immediate difference when I put them on. And I'm convinced that they aid in my recovery by promoting circulation in my knees and upper body.You might try it and see if it has any effect on your cramping issue.Best, John

Calf cramps

 I've been biking for years and used to get wicked calf cramps while sleeping. Last year a pedaled about 1,000 miles, I have had some years with up to 3,000.  My first solution to calf cramps was to anticipate them coming on during my sleep, jump out of bed before they got bad and then I'd do a diagonal plank against the wall to pull the cramp out.  Previously I developed Plantae Fascinates from overextending my foot on a bike that was set too large for me.  I also got a frozen shoulder from being too hunched over on the bike.  During the past two years I've been working with a personal trainer and have pretty much eliminated the cramps, Plantae Fascinates, and the frozen shoulder.  His general thought was that my body was out of balance, strong calf, weak core, Gluteus and Quads along with limited side to side movement.  This situation caused an overuse of my strong calves when I went biking.  After about 10,000 lunges, squats, chest presses, arm stretches, sit-ups, other upper body work, a cortisone shot in the shoulder, buying a properly sized bike and having it fit correctly everything is in much better balance.  I don't get the cramps, my planter fascinates is about gone and my shoulder is all loosened up.  I think the balanced body concept was totally lost on me for years.   Marc Webb 

Cramps

Calf cramps had vexed me for years.  It was particularly difficult following fatigue onset, maybe fluids depletion and with continued high-cadence pedaling (95-105). About 5 years ago I move from a flat-land cycling environment to a very significant hill cycling environment.  Leg cramping increased and would put me off the road wondering how I would get off the bike without both masses ending up as a twisted roadkill.  Lack of fluids and general fatigue were not the main cause, though they would certainly add to the problem.   I tried more calcium.  No good.  Then I increased my vitamin D3 supplemental intake with nearly remarkable results. My suplemental calcium intake is about 3 tablets x 600 mg each containing, in addition, 400 iu of vitamin D3.  My extra suplemental vitamin D3 intake is now one 5000 iu capsule per day.  That increases my suplemental D3 intake to over 6000 iu.  The additional vitimin D3 has not only banished the cramps, but also considerably reduced my potential for small skin lesions associated with riding, sweat, heat friction, etc.Now the cramps in the legs come if I don't ride enough to maintain good muscle tone, along with the so-called restless leg syndrome. 

Choresterol

I share the same struggles with genes and a naturally high chloresterol/LDL level.Two things that I have found...1. the more advanced scientists that look at this talk about two different types of LDL (yes even it has good and bad sides it seems).  They are large particle and small particle.  Large particle LDL is fine. Small particle LDL builds plaque.  If you have plaque evident from a scan then it may be interesting to ask your doctor to tell you the amount of big vs small LDL2. Reason being that large LDL is supposed to come from meat/dairy, but small LDL is produced more by wheat-originated produce and is heavily influenced by the insulin cycle (and thus related to glycemic index stuff)There is a guy who is a heart surgeon who claims to have fixed a lot of these supposedly hereditary challenges by getting people to "imagine" they have caeliacs and adopt a gluten-free diet.I would prefer that to muscle cramps and a life on statins.As usual DYOR everyone - but it is worth exploring.  Amongst some of my friends this approach has not only helped their heart health but reduced incidences of IBS, helped them drop weight etc etc. 

Three comments

It would be really nice if the Lance haters who insisted on the grand jury would now fade to the background.  Your sabotage didn't work.  Get over it.Wondering why Contrador is getting credit toward his 2 year ban for time he spent racing.  Resistence/strength training rocks.  This winter I stumbled into a pack of comrade Russian kettlebell experts taught by Pavel.  My strength has rocketed.  Combined with paleo to keep my weight down, I've avoided bulk and gotten supremely satisfying strength at age 60.  It seems to be paying off on the computrainer.   It will be good to see what happens when it comes time to get out on the road again.IceManScott Richardson   

Crank Length

I have to wonder about how people have their saddle hight set in relation to crank length especialy in relation to the rise in hight of the knee vs the maxing out of leg length using long cranks and the impact this has on closing up the chest area when the cranks are at TDC especially those who have low profile on a time trial bike.  The impact of trying to push big gears when you should be changing down will result in your muscles dealing with an increase in torque being applied to hte peddles which in turn increases the recruitment of fast twitch muscle fibers which in turn prefer to use carbohydates as a fuel since they lack the enzymes necessary to process high quantities of fat - so unless your Carb stores are well stocked you could be in trouble depending on the lenght of the event. 

crank length

I have experimented with different crank lengths over the years and have found that longer cranks are better for standing on hills, and for shorter, more hilly TT courses where you need to accelerate often. For longer, more steady courses the shorter ones are better. Also, if you have a high cadence (i consider >85 high), then shorter are better. I too have noticed better TT times with shorter cranks - initially. However, I think the times degrade after the initial improvement. I think that training with a little longer crank and then racing shorter ones gives the best racing results.  This all said, last year I did the Lookout mtn. TT in Golden twice, once with 180's and once with 170's and my times were within 2 seconds of eachother!

Crankarm length

Thanks for the feedback and sharing your experience with different length crankarms, Colorado Roadie. Much appreciated and very interesting results!Thank you!Jim Langley

Flabby Core? Tone Up and Improve Your Cycling

Laurel-Lea, Thanks for the 4 great no-equipment core building exercises! I intend to use them. I have one problem with "The Plank", as demonstrated by Plant. He is reaised up with his toes bent. I am 58, and I have arthritis in both of my big toes. Weight-bearing with toes bent is very painful and will cause swelling of the joint. As a modification of this exercise, how about if I point my toes (like a ballerina!) and support my legs on the tops of my feet? I believe this wil relieve the toe joint stress, and just require a bit more ankle strength. Steve - Brownsville, OR

Crank Arm Length

Jim,    Great article on crank arm length.  I've been in the bike business for 25+ years, and couldn't agree more with your conclusions.   The shorter-arm revelation came to me about 15 years ago, when a knee injury ended my running career.  At 5'9" I've now got 170s on all my personal bikes, including my mountain bike, and totally suffer not! from the difference.  I tell customers with confidence, that unless they have extremely long legs they have no need for long crank arms; shorter arms will save their knees and make them pedal much more smoothly.Paul Ahart, Friday Harbor, WA

Crankarm length

Hi Paul,Thanks for the kind words and sharing your expertise on crankarms,Jim  

Good issue/crank arms

Really good issue of the newsletter.  Thanks.  I especially liked the 411 on shorter crank arms.  At 60 and a triathlete, my coach has been giving me fits about the need for a smoother stroke. Looking forward to the intel on the carbon crank next week.Also, nice touch on the drawing for premium members.  I joined a few years ago to support the newletter because I think it's one of the best.  I will renew this year.  Thanks. IceMan.  

Thanks, Iceman!

Your comments are much appreciated! We'll keep working hard to continue to try to improve RBR. Thanks for being a Premium Member.Best,John

Pro bike fit poll - need another option

Would love to answer this week's poll, but as of 8:30 EST you left out what I consider an obvious choice: "No, but would like to have one done." The two "No" choices assume that anyone who answers "No" sees no value in a pro fitting session. That certainly doesn't apply to me, and I suspect it is true of many others as well.

Sorry

I do my best to provide a range of possible responses. But I'll be the first the admit that I don't always get it right! (On this, and other things as well.  ;-)   Believe it or not, to me the QoW is one the hardest parts of putting together the newsletter every week.I'd love for readers to submit questions they'd like to see answered -- along with possible responses.I'll keep working on it.Best,John

Fixing the Unfixable

Congratulations on a clever repair!  I find great satisfaction in fixing things that can't be fixed.  (I was the maintenance man at a 7-12 grade boarding school for years.  Had to fix things that couldn't be fixed all the time.)  The real hero in this story, though, is VICE GRIPS!  How long have they been around?  And still as marvelous a tool as ever.  But, you gotta get good ones!  Lots of cheapies out there.

Andy's Bike Shop

Jim, I lived in Keene from 1993-96 and I believe Andy's was the bike shop I used. Was it the one one Rte 9?

Andy's

Hi Kenn42,It might be, but it's been a long time since I've been back to Keene and I know Bruce moved his shop, but I'm not certain where he relocated it. When I worked at Andy's it was on Main Street in downtown.Thanks,Jim Langley

Losing those last 10 pounds

Congratulations, John, on losing those last 10 pounds.  I said when I wrote that article that if I helped one person lose 10 pounds it was worth it.  Didn't know it was going to be you!

Slow recovery

Don't forget to have some blood work done as well. I was terribly tired for months, putting it down to reduced fitness and age but it got so bad I went to the doc. Severe vitamin D deficiency; go figure. Now on a big dose of vitamin D and improving already, a month later.

Weight loss

I'm also 5'-10".  I'm currently up to 135 lbs.  I had dropped to 129 lbs and decided that was as low as I desired.  Eight years ago I had gone down to 126 lbs.